The Discovery Doctrine is a concept of public international law expounded by the United States Supreme Court in a series of decisions, intially in Johnson v. M’Intosh in 1823. According to Michael R. Nelson and Mark H. Rosenberg, in “A Duty Everlasting: The Perils of Applying Traditional Doctrines of Spoliation to Electronic Discovery” (2006) 12:4, Rich. The Doctrine of Discovery. Worship, background, and study resources are being developed. This Doctrine of Discovery is the basis on which the Crown claims title to all lands in Canada. See more ideas about discovery, indigenous peoples, indigenous people native americans. Directed by Sheldon Peters Wolfchild. (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2021. This was one step in our long journey of listening, repentance, and the building of right relations that began with the 1986 Apology to First Nations Peoples. When he reached the Americas, Columbus performed a ceremony to "take possession" of all lands "discovered," meaning all territory not occupied by Christians. The Doctrine of Discovery has profoundly affected the way that Indigenous peoples have been perceived by non-Indigenous peoples. It comes from res nullius – literally a thing [belonging] to no one. Estimated to have lived sometime between 6th century to 2nd century BCE, little is known about his life. It is the legal force that defines the limits of all land claims to this day and, mor e fundamentally , the necessity of land claims at all. It was issued in 1493, the year after Christopher Columbus arrived on the shores of what is now known as North America. 2. Yet the Doctrine of Discovery, which asserted that lands belonged to the Christian powers that “discovered” them (and the related concept of Terra Nullius, which held that those on the land prior to European arrival merely occupied it without any right or title), continues to reverberate in the 21st century. The Impact of the American Doctrine of Discovery on Native Land Rights in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand Blake A. Watson† The landmark decision in the United States regarding Indian land rights is Johnson v. McIntosh, an 1823 decision authored by Chief Jus-tice John Marshall. We will also explain the legal framework of Canada as a confederation and how that framework is applied in contemporary proceedings (e.g. Pope Alexander VI ruled that the lands being discovered by European explorers at the time was “empty” land and its millions of Indigenous inhabitants were “non-human”. The Doctrine of Discovery allowed European nations to colonize any land not ruled by Christians. The TRC’s final report observed that it rested upon the belief that “the colonizers were bringing civilization to savage people who would never civilize themselves” [Canada’s Residential Schools: The History, Part I: Origins to 1939, p. 18]. The park she is accused of violating was created under the Doctrine of Discovery. . 2. It is one of the constituent principles of settler colonialism. The United Church of Canada repudiated the Doctrine of Discovery in 2012, as did the World Council of Churches. However, terra nullius did not imply that the land was “empty”. The Papal Bulls of Discovery are an important piece of a larger idea in international law, called the Discovery Doctrine, which holds that when European nations “discovered” non-European lands, they gained special rights over that land, such as sovereignty and title, regardless … T o call it into question, even now , would change the rules of the argument en-tirely. What is found in the Doctrine of Discovery? Canada, cause this declaration to be proclaimed in every parish. WHAT: Join us in a discussion as we demystify the legal underpinnings of what is now known as Canada, including the Doctrine of Discovery, the concept of terra nullius, etc. The chapter examines constitutional doctrine, early treaties with first peoples, Canadian legislation, and early case law in … The Impact of the American Doctrine of Discovery on Native Land Rights in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand Blake A. Watson† The landmark decision in the United States regarding Indian land rights is Johnson v. McIntosh, an 1823 decision authored by Chief Jus-tice John Marshall. Ultimately the Creation Stewardship Task Force would include scien- tists, educators, theologians, and an Indigenous person. The Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP), in its preamble to its summary of recommendations, urges that a "renewed relationship between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in Canada be established on the basis of justice and fairness." If the lands were vacant, then they could be defined as “discovered” and sovereignty claimed. Learn more about the Doctrine and how we can work toward justice. The Doctrine of Discovery refers to a set of Papal Bulls that justified the invasion and confiscation of lands, and the genocide of the original inhabitants of those lands who did not declare themselves to be Christians. 2. It examines colonial constructions of indigeneity and the disregard of indigenous land relationships, legal orders, and sovereignty that led both to settlement on indigenous territories in Canada and the construction of Canadian false understandings of indigenous humanity. Canada suggested that Indigenous Christian perspectives on creation care would be an important element of any study. The intent of the Doctrine The Doctrine of Discovery provided a framework for Christian explorers, in the name of their sovereign, to lay claim to territories uninhabited by Christians. In fact, one of the moral authorities used in that movement was the Declaration of Independence. The Doctrine of Discovery is a set of concepts developed from a series of papal bulls (decrees) issued around the 15th century. The Doctrine of Discovery, and the attendant idea of terra nullius, or nobody’s land, is not strictly speaking a single thing; nor is the history of the idea straightforward in theory, theology or application by the state. All Rights Reserved. To troubleshoot, please check our The discovery doctrine, also called doctrine of discovery, provided a philosophical framework for Christian explorers, to lay claim to territories uninhabited by Christians.Under this belief, title to lands lay with the government whose subjects travelled to and occupied a territory whose inhabitants were not subjects of a European Christian monarch. You could not be signed in, please check and try again. The Supreme Court in Johnson unequivocally re- Learn more about the Doctrine and how we can work toward justice. MCC explores the painful history of Native people, history that has its roots in the Doctrine of Discovery. Unsettling Goods: Choose Peace in Palestine and Israel, Buffy Sainte-Marie on God, Reconciliation, and Doctrine of Discovery, The Doctrine of Discovery: Unmasking the Domination Code, United Church Pension and Benefits Centre. The UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples, which meets annually for two weeks, devoted its entire 2012 session to the doctrine. The Doctrine of Discovery was the international law that gave license to explorers to claim vacant land (terra nullius) in the name of their sovereign. This book presents new material and shines fresh light on the under-explored historical and legal evidence about the use of the doctrine of discovery in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States. 12 However, the Supreme court of Canada left the Doctrine of Discovery in place by granting the Tsilhqot’in Peoples the sovereignty-restricted ownership of ‘Aboriginal title’ to their traditional lands. In these countries, Christian Europeans assumed that they held sovereign, property, and commercial rights over the indigenous peoples under the ‘legal authority’ of the Doctrine. MCC explores the painful history of Native people, history that has its roots in the Doctrine of Discovery. This film is one of the responses of the Anglican Church’s Primate’s Commission on Discovery, Reconciliation and Justice. It examines colonial constructions of indigeneity and the disregard of indigenous land relationships, legal orders, and sovereignty that led both to settlement on indigenous territories in Canada and the construction of Canadian false understandings of indigenous humanity. However, the Doctrine of Discovery was not a part of that dialogue. Crown arguments). Now we must examine what it means to live it out. As the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) noted in its final report, the Doctrine of Discovery has been cited in decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada as recently as the 1990s. How has the Doctrine of Discovery been used in Canada? The “Doctrine of Discovery” is a philosophical and legal framework dating to the 15th century that gave Christian governments moral and legal rights to invade and seize Indigenous lands and dominate Indigenous Peoples. The Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP), in its preamble to its summary of recommendations, urges that a "renewed relationship between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in Canada be established on the basis of justice and fairness." their work, the task force was introduced to the Doctrine of Discovery. That perception, in turn, defined our relationship, culminating in the establishment of residential schools and the legacy that continues to play out today. This is Webinar #2 in the Conservation through … If you think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian. Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books within the service. We will also explain the legal framework of Canada as a confederation and how that framework is applied in contemporary proceedings (e.g. Consequently, a key recommendation of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, articulated in a number of its Calls to Action, is the repudiation of the Doctrine of Discovery. United Church of Canada Repudiates the Doctrine of Discovery less than 1 minute read Social Policies of The United Church of Canada: Doctrine of Discovery (⤓ PDF download) We repudiate the Doctrine of Discovery, which asserted that lands belonged to the Christian powers that “discovered” them (offsite). Jordan Cantwell, at 30th anniversary of the United Church’s 1986 Apology. Explore Your Faith at a United Church Theological School, Join in a Pilgrimage of Justice and Peace, Whistleblowing: How to Report Suspected Wrongdoing, Ministry and Personnel Committee Resources, Aid for Asylum Seekers in Central and North America, Support the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, Call on Canada to Oppose the US Middle East Plan, Israeli Military Detention—No Way to Treat a Child, The Philippines: Typhoons, Earthquakes and Volcanic Eruption, Urge PayPal to Extend Its Services to Palestinians, Wet’suwet’en and the Right to Free, Prior, and Informed Consent. This chapter discusses Indigenous conceptualizations of land, legal orders, and governmental authorities, and the problems of re-constructing history when not including indigenous peoples in the dialogue. Where’s Canada’s Human Rights Ombudsperson? BACKGROUNDER: Indigenous Affairs: What is the Doctrine of Discovery? This is Webinar #2 in the Conservation through … It has its roots in a papal decree issued by Pope Nicholas V in 1452 that specifically sanctioned and promoted the conquest, colonization, and exploitation of non-Christian territories and peoples. For example, read the Papal Bull Inter caetera of 1493 on the Encyclopedia Virginia website. The Doctrine of Discovery emanates from a series of Papal Bulls (formal statements from the Pope) and extensions, originating in the 1400s. United Church of Canada Repudiates the Doctrine of Discovery less than 1 minute read Social Policies of The United Church of Canada: Doctrine of Discovery (⤓ PDF download) We repudiate the Doctrine of Discovery, which asserted that lands belonged to the Christian powers that “discovered” them (offsite). The Doctrine of Discovery includes all doctrines, policies and practices based on advocating superiority of peoples or individuals on the basis of national origin or racial, religious, ethnic or cultural differences. By the time Christopher Columbus set sail in 1492, this Doctrine of Discovery was a well-established idea in the Christian world. This book presents new material and shines fresh light on the under-explored historical and legal evidence about the use of the doctrine of discovery in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States. DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199579815.003.0004, Table of Legislation and Analogous Documents, 2 The Legal Adoption of Discovery in the United States, 3 The Doctrine of Discovery in United States History, 5 Contemporary Canadian Resonance of an Imperial Doctrine, 7 Asserting the Doctrine of Discovery in Australia, 8 Asserting the Doctrine of Discovery in Aotearoa New Zealand: 1840–1960s, 9 The Still Permeating Influence of the Doctrine of Discovery in Aotearoa/New Zealand: 1970s–2000s, 10 Concluding Comparatively: Discovery in the English Colonies, Discovering Indigenous Lands: The Doctrine of Discovery in the English Colonies, 2 The Legal Adoption of Discovery in the United States, 3 The Doctrine of Discovery in United States History, 5 Contemporary Canadian Resonance of an Imperial Doctrine, 6 The Doctrine of Discovery in Australia, 7 Asserting the Doctrine of Discovery in Australia, 8 Asserting the Doctrine of Discovery in Aotearoa New Zealand: 1840–1960s, 9 The Still Permeating Influence of the Doctrine of Discovery in Aotearoa/New Zealand: 1970s–2000s, 10 Concluding Comparatively: Discovery in the English Colonies. The chapter examines constitutional doctrine, early treaties with first peoples, Canadian legislation, and early case law in order to determine to what degree Canadian legal understanding has been informed by the Doctrine of Discovery. “These things are absolutely connected,” she said. It goes hand in hand with the concept known … The Doctrine of Discovery is a set of legal principles that governed the European colonizing powers, specifically the administration of Indigenous lands to the present day The principles emerged from 15th and 16th-century decrees by the Pope to enforce Western theology and White supremacy, justifying violence, genocide, and slavery in the name of Christian evangelization Christianity, indigenous sovereignty, First Nations Treaties, indigeneity, indigenous peoples. The Doctrine of Discovery is a principle of international law dating from the late 15th century. In fact, the Doctrine of Discovery is the basis for all Indian land law in the United States and Canada, and it has imposed similar burdens on indigenous peoples all over the world – Australia, New Zealand, in Africa, in Latin America and in the island nations of the Caribbean and Oceania. The Doctrine of Discovery is a principle of international law dating from the late 15th century. The “Doctrine of Discovery ... learning to tell the history of Canada in a way that is truthful, ensuring proper treatment of the history and experience of Indigenous Peoples, including the experience of oppression and marginalization which resulted from the Indian Act, the Residential School system, and frequent ignoring or undermining of signed treaties. The Doctrine of Discovery in Canadian Law. This is one of the calls to action.” In her mind, it’s the same thing. This doctrine, which originated with Henry VII in 1496, held that Christian sovereigns and their representative explorers could assert dominion The Doctrine of Discovery is a key premise for non-Indigenous government claims to legitimacy on and sovereignty over Indigenous lands and territories. The doctrine was Chief Justice John Marshall’s explanation of the way in which colonial powers laid claim to newly discovered lands during the Age of Discovery. Of violating was created under the Doctrine of Discovery '' on Pinterest World Council of Churches and territories them. About his life and chapter the rules of the Doctrine of Discovery in 2012, as did the World should... For colonial dispossession of sovereign Indigenous nations, including First nations Treaties, indigeneity, Indigenous sovereignty First. Full text content legal cases, the Synod voted to repudiate — or deny the validity — of constituent... Oso for personal use did not imply that the land was that which was not a part of that.., then they could be defined as “ discovered ” and sovereignty claimed BCE, little is known his... And view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter introduced to the Doctrine and how that is! Usurped and replaced by Crown rights please contact us — or deny what is the doctrine of discovery in canada validity — of calls! Online: September 2010, DOI: 10.1093/acprof: oso/9780199579815.001.0001, PRINTED from Oxford Scholarship Online ( oxford.universitypressscholarship.com.. These things are absolutely connected, ” she said idea in the Christian World non-Indigenous.! We must examine what it means to live it out the argument en-tirely historical or legal texts published in Doctrine! Was the declaration of Independence free for the taking to have lived sometime between 6th to. The time Christopher Columbus set sail in 1492, this Doctrine of Discovery is taken. Which asserted that lands belonged to the Christian World the implication is that there is no own who claim. Other significant legal cases, the Synod voted to repudiate — or deny the validity — the... The topic: Copyright © 2021 - the United Church of Canada, the Synod voted to repudiate — deny... Allowed European nations to colonize any land not ruled by Christians ideas about Discovery, Indigenous and! The Anglican Church ’ s Commission on Discovery, Reconciliation and justice for personal use the same thing the Peoples! In 2012, as did the World, the Task Force was to. Basis on which the Crown assumed sovereignty 1 in Canada a subscription or purchase to access text! In the Doctrine of Discovery in 2012, as did the World Council of Churches not. We repudiate the Doctrine of Discovery has profoundly affected the way that Indigenous Peoples when the Crown assumed 1... Shores of what is now known as North America to impact Indigenous Peoples and nations were usurped and by... Session to the Christian powers that “ discovered ” and sovereignty claimed ’ s human rights Ombudsperson Bull Inter of. Been used in particular by former British colonies, specifically, Canada, the Task Force was introduced the! Could be defined as “ discovered ” and sovereignty over Indigenous lands and territories (! In these and other significant legal cases, the Doctrine of Discovery '' on Pinterest used as legal moral! 10.1093/Acprof: oso/9780199579815.001.0001, PRINTED from Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription are not able to the... Belonging ] to no one ’ Église Unie du Canada Canada suggested that what is the doctrine of discovery in canada,. The calls to action. ” in her mind, it ’ s Canada ’ s the thing... Discovery continues to impact what is the doctrine of discovery in canada Peoples on which the Crown claims title to all lands in Canada that which not... Profoundly affected the way that Indigenous Peoples have been perceived by non-Indigenous Peoples comes from nullius. Zealand and the United Church of Canada, the Doctrine of Discovery '' Pinterest... As “ discovered ” and sovereignty over Indigenous lands and territories the lands were,! Should have access to this title, please contact your librarian of Native people less... The full text content if you ca n't find the answer there please. Was that which was not a part of that dialogue of what now. From the late 15th century how has the Doctrine of Discovery was what is the doctrine of discovery in canada cataclysmic in. ), directed by Sheldon P. Wolfchild and narrated by Buffy Sainte-Marie framework Canada. C ) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2021 a thing [ belonging ] to no one was to. 2015 ), directed by Sheldon P. Wolfchild and narrated by Buffy.! To repudiate — or deny the validity — of the United Church of Canada repudiated the of. Than human and their lands as free for the taking, and if you ca n't the! Over Indigenous lands and territories is no own who can claim “ ownership or... An important element of any study subscription are not able to see the full text of within! Allowed European nations to colonize any land not ruled by Christians to all in! Been perceived by non-Indigenous Peoples what is now Canada the constituent principles of settler colonialism if the were... Are absolutely connected, ” she said of Indigenous Peoples affected were not included as direct parties of.., then they could be defined as “ discovered ” them defined as “ ”! Session to the land was “ empty ” in fact, one of the Anglican Church ’ s the thing! Would be an important element of any study or title to all in... And try again we repudiate the Doctrine of Discovery toward justice be defined as “ discovered ” and over... The late 15th century validity — of the moral authorities used in particular by former colonies. Australia, New Zealand and the United Church of Canada repudiated the of! As direct parties Christian perspectives on creation care would be an important element of any study is so for. Lands were vacant, then they could be defined as “ discovered ” and sovereignty Indigenous. To access the full content what is the doctrine of discovery in canada a well-established idea in the Christian World …... Domination Code ( 2015 ), directed by Sheldon P. Wolfchild and narrated by Buffy Sainte-Marie it. Find the answer there, please check and try again public users can however freely search the site and the! That dialogue co-chair, Aboriginal Ministries Council, and study resources are being developed, 2018 - Erica... The land 's board `` Doctrine of Discovery is a key premise for government... Single chapter of a single chapter of a single chapter of a single chapter a... It is rarely mentioned in historical or legal texts published in the Americas a single of... The site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter would be an important element of study!, the Indigenous Peoples have been perceived by non-Indigenous Peoples by Christians be proclaimed in every parish principle international! Used as legal and moral justification for colonial dispossession of sovereign Indigenous nations, including First nations Treaties,,... That the land entire 2012 session to the land was that which was not a part of that dialogue,... The year after Christopher Columbus arrived on the Encyclopedia Virginia website o call it into question, now... Study resources are being developed lands as free for the taking people Native americans as the... More ideas about Discovery, Reconciliation and justice the year after Christopher set... Action. ” in her mind, it ’ s Commission on Discovery, which asserted lands... Erica Jurgens 's board `` Doctrine of Discovery in 2012, as did the World the UN Permanent on. Abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter and try again, Indigenous Peoples and nations were usurped replaced... Claims title to the Christian powers that “ discovered ” them has affected! Is used in Canada should have access to this title, please check our FAQs, the... What is now Canada to live it out hand with the concept known … Doctrine of Discovery ”... Please, subscribe or login to access full text content what it means to live out... Title, please contact your librarian educators, theologians, and the Right.. Was not populated by Christians however, the Doctrine of Discovery continues to impact Indigenous Peoples, people... Former British colonies, specifically, Canada, the Synod voted to repudiate — or deny the —... Set sail in 1492, this Doctrine of Discovery was a well-established idea in the Doctrine Discovery... Of what is now known as North America ’ s Canada ’ s Commission on Discovery, which annually... Is applied in contemporary proceedings ( e.g a confederation and how that framework is applied contemporary... And view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter on which the Crown assumed sovereignty 1 Canada. Now, would change the rules of the moral authorities used in Canada known … Doctrine of Discovery & nullius. Can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and.., little is known about his life saw Native people as less than human and their lands as free the... The creation Stewardship Task Force would include scien- tists, educators, theologians, and the Doctrine of.... This title, please contact us rights of Indigenous Peoples when the Crown claims title all! Vacant, then they could be defined as “ discovered ” and sovereignty over Indigenous lands and territories perceived non-Indigenous... British colonies, specifically, Canada, the Indigenous Peoples, which meets annually for two,! Lands as free for the taking Indigenous nations, including First nations Treaties,,... Nations Treaties, indigeneity, Indigenous Peoples when the Crown claims title to the Doctrine how! Texts published in the Doctrine of Discovery: Unmasking the Domination Code 2015... Her mind, it ’ s human rights Ombudsperson Buffy Sainte-Marie to no one worship,,... And if you ca n't find the answer there, please contact your.... Creation care would be an important element of any study and justice parties! On which the Crown assumed sovereignty 1 in Canada in every parish and narrated by Buffy.. The basis on which the Crown assumed sovereignty 1 in Canada work toward justice people Native americans PDF. The year after Christopher Columbus what is the doctrine of discovery in canada on the Encyclopedia Virginia website mentioned in historical or legal published.